Blogs > Saratogian Newsroom

The Saratogian Newsroom blog, complete with thoughts and commentary from our newsroom staff and regular posts on happenings around town.

Wednesday, February 11

The 'Forgotten Neighborhood,' not satisfied

After my article in today's Saratogian about the issues between residents of the west side neighborhood sandwiched between St. Charles Place, West Avenue and Grand Avenue and the Developers Steven Kamen and Steven Komp, I received a phone message from one very dissatisfied area resident.

A Mr. Al Bonacio, presumably father of developer Sonny Bonaccio, called to express his displeasure.

"The articel is slanted toward the developers, and didn't help us at all," he alleges. For the record, Mr. Bonaccio was not present at a Tuesday afternoon press conference that I attended, though his wife, Linda, was.

Well, I suppose that when you call in the press, offer them stories about how tightly knit the community is, with people plowing each other's driveways and building wheelchair ramps, and claim that the developers are ruining the neighborhood's character, you expect the story's sole source.

I think that our readers deserve a more balanced approach, and that is why I reached out to the developers. When the developers tell me that they intend to find a way to make good on the neighbor's complaints, I have no reason not to take them at their word, and so that perspective gets written in to the story. The alternative would have been to serve as the resident's mouthpeice, and that is not my job.

Mr. Bonaccio also asked if we had read the group's position paper, which details the resident's complaints against Kamen and Komp. The answer is that yes, I did. It is true that the neighbors have listed several instances in which the developers have not made good on their word. I was not able to independantly jerify any of these, and as such, I didn't think it was fair to rake anyone over the coals.

However, I did leave one question unanswered in yesterday's story, and that is the question of enforcement. The city Planning Board is responsible for guiding development through the planning process, it is not their job to ensure that plans are followed to a 'T.' That is the role of the city's building department, which has responded to Kamen's failure to meet his approved site plane by granting him only temporary certificates of occupancy, which have been renewed every six months.

Should the building department have sharper teath?

6 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

We understand it is your job to report both sides of a story. Whose job is it to determine which side is being honest and which side spins the truth. Yes, we need stronger a stronger building department, without a doubt.

February 12, 2009 at 5:59 AM 
Blogger Sara native said...

I understand it is your job, Andrew, to report both sides of a story. Whose job is it to determine who is being honest and who is spinning the truth. Yes we do need a stronger building department.

February 12, 2009 at 6:33 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Andrew J. Bernstein:

You ask, "Should the building department have sharper teeth?"

First, let's try giving them a better boss. The building department is under the mayor's office. Where's Mayor Johnson? You won't find him anywhere near City Hall on a February day because he's off sunning himself in Florida.

Do-nothing Johnson doesn't have a clue and doesn't give a damn. Time for a new mayor.

February 12, 2009 at 7:50 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes and no. I'm not sure how they determine who to hammer. I had a friend who was forced to rebuild a set of 3 stairs on his deck because they were 1/2 inch too short. It was noted as a safety hazard. Yet I walk all around town trying not to break my neck on ice covered sidewalks and big developers apparently get repeated 6 month reprieves for not completing a major portion of their site plan. To me, it seems as though they have the teeth, but they are very discretionary as to when they use them.

February 12, 2009 at 8:46 AM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mayor Johnson is afraid to act against developers. They are the only support he has in this town. His promises were all lies and the truth will eventually set us free of him.

February 12, 2009 at 4:58 PM 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

What's everyone so worried about? Real estate is just gonna keep going up and up right? The more building the better! I don't think these developers have made enough money yet. Gee, small town developers with deep pockets getting there way, big fucking surprise. Hey, if anyone need a loan to buy any of the new units, I know a mortgage guy!!!! HA HA HA

February 12, 2009 at 9:44 PM 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home